Farm in family since 1772


Editor’s Note – This is the first in a new series of stories authored by Robert Kroeger about eight old barns in Adams County. Kroeger paints the barns, usually framed with actual wood from the barn depicted, and includes some history of the barn with the painting. The paintings will be auctioned off Oct. 28 during a fundraiser for the Adams County Humane Society at the GE Employee Pavilion near Peebles. Kroeger has painted 23 barns in Highland County with most of them featured in past editions of The Times-Gazette. This painting is titled “Eight Generations.”

Ironically, the oldest continuously family-owned farm in Ohio is one of the most difficult to find. I followed my car’s GPS, which led me down rural Adams County roads, past a drive sign posted to an old farm open to the public for “Pioneer Days.” But that wasn’t the one I wanted. So, I kept going and heard the message from my GPS lady that I had arrived at my destination.

An unmarked road, leading up a hill, was my only option; so I turned up the hill and pulled around a farmhouse where I met two of the Smileys. One was the farm’s owner, John Smiley, and the other was his son James, the eighth generation of Smileys. James has two sons, who represent generation number nine. On the map, this road is named Smiley Road. In reality, it is unmarked.

I sat on the porch and chatted with John, the seventh generation of his family. He had just returned from a tractor pull. He won third place, good for $90, more than covering his $20 entry.

“It beats farming,” he joked.

John told me that his ancestor, Alexander Smiley, an Englishman, was granted 500 acres of this land by King George III in 1772, four years before the Declaration of Independence. Why here? Why then? This was wild, uncharted territory, the uncharted Northwest Territory, and most definitely Indian country – land of the Shawnees, Miamis, Mingos and Delawares. It was a time of frontiersmen.

One of them, Simon Kenton, a peer of Daniel Boone, who turned 17 in 1772, had fled his Virginia home a year earlier after he thought he had killed a boy flirting with his girlfriend. The lad survived, but Kenton didn’t return home, instead choosing the life of a scout and Indian fighter in what is now Ohio, Kentucky and West Virginia. He was a natural in the woods and in 1774, two years after Smiley established his farm, Kenton served as a scout for settlers – British colonists – in Lord Dunsmore’s War, pitting them against the Shawnee and Mingo tribes. Even though the war ended in 1774, fighting between the settlers and Indians continued for over 20 years in Ohio.

Kenton was captured twice by the Shawnees, who respected him as a great warrior, but forced him to run the gauntlet. He survived – twice. All this while Alexander Smiley was farming in the hills of Adams County. It must have been a time of great adventures.

The original farmhouse Alexander Smiley built burned down. Another was built in 1813 and lasted almost 200 years before it, too, burned. John told me he was born in this house in 1952, as was his father – in 1915.

John and his son James still use this old barn, built in the 1800s, raising Charolais cattle as well as corn, soybeans, wheat and hay. Their 600 acres provides a good living for them and allows the Smiley heritage to continue, which is also the hope of this painting and essay.

Robert Kroeger is a former Cincinnati area dentist who has since ran in and organized marathons, took up the painting skills he first picked up from his commercial artist father, become a published author, and is a certified personal trainer that started the LifeNuts vitality program. Visit his website at

This barn in Adams County reportedly rests on the oldest continuously family-owned farm in Ohio, dating to 1772. barn in Adams County reportedly rests on the oldest continuously family-owned farm in Ohio, dating to 1772.
Nine generations of Smiley family have lived on Adams County farm

By Robert Kroeger

No posts to display